The prefecture launched its request for proposals to find an integrated resort operator in December 2019, but received only one bid. The prefecture government noted, though, that the bid was highly ambitious and could greatly help Osaka’s economy recover from the effects of the novel coronavirus (Covid-19) pandemic.
“By deeply understanding the purpose and purpose of the project, looking at the post-Covid recovery, and realizing a growth-type IR that makes use of the tourism attractions of Osaka and Kansai and the potential of industrial and cultural resources, it will become the engine of economic growth in Osaka and Kansai, and will become the engine of Osaka,” it said.
“It is a very ambitious proposal to take the city brand to a new level of international competitiveness.”
The MGM-Orix bid was scored on five areas, for a total score of 788.5 points out of 1,000. The most significant of these was whether the businesses’ financial strength and implementation of their bid would ensure business stability. Here, the bid scored 254.5 points out of 300.
For the quality and “uniqueness” of its concept, the bid scored 204 out of 260 points. When scored for thereation of high-quality and unique international tourism bases, the bid received 152.5 points out of a possible 200.
The bid was also scored for its implementation of countermeasures to prevent concerns such as gambling-related harm. Here, the bid scored 101.5 points out of a possible 140.
Finally, when it came to building a foundation for an attractive and sustainable IR that contributes to the community, the bid scored 76 points out of 100.
“It is highly expected that the Osaka IR will contribute to the growth of the Osaka / Kansai economy and the leveling up of the tourism industry, as well as the introduction of tourism and economic promotion in Japan as a whole,” the prefecture added.
In its bid documents, MGM and Orix said the initial investment in the project would come to JPY1.8trn (£11.84bn/€13.85bn/$16.17bn). The consortium added that it expected annual sales of around JPY540bn, of which JPY430m would be from gaming, with the prefecture receiving JPY77bn per year.
The bidders anticipate around 20.5m visitors per year. Of those visitors, it said, it expected around 6.5m to be from overseas and the remainder to be from Japan.
The resort would be set to employ 15,000 people.
Both bids were not without controversy, however. In Wakayama, anonymous documents were circulated, alleging that William Weidner – president of Gaming Asset Management, which is advising Clairvest – is unsuitable to be involved with the bid due to conduct during his time as president of Las Vegas Sands.
The documents were addressed to Japan Casino Regulatory Commission, Wakayama Prefecture Government, Clairvest and its Wakayama arm Clairvest Neem Ventures. However, ICE365 has confirmed that three addressees did not receive them and did not get a response from JCRC.
Weidner terms the documents “sophisticated but unsubstantiated name calling” containing nothing “that would constitute criminal activity.”
In Nagasaki, meanwhile, Oshidori International Development – one of three finalists – announced that it had withdrawn from the bidding process days before the prefecture would announce a winning bid.
Oshidori said it did not approve of the development and operation rules imposed by the prefecture and that the request for proposals process was not being implemented ethically or fairly.
In a statement, the business also said it had encountered “multiple suspicions of ethical fraud in the RFP process”. It concluded that it could only participate in a selection process which is transparent and professional.