Home > Sports betting > Clase Trial: Jurors review improbable Pages strike that cost bettors thousands

Clase Trial: Jurors review improbable Pages strike that cost bettors thousands

| By Matt Rybaltowski | Reading Time: 4 minutes
A key witness claims he received inside info that the bet was rigged, claims the defense believes are patently wrong
Pages

Despite a memorable, game-saving catch in the final game of the 2025 World Series, Andy Pages is known just as much for another clip that went viral.

Months before Pages’ acrobatic catch in Toronto, the Los Angeles Dodgers outfielder faced Emmanuel Clase in an early-season matchup. With the Cleveland Guardians leading the Dodgers 7-4 in the top of the ninth inning, Pages swung at the first pitch from Clase — an 89 mile per hour slider in the dirt.

The strike garnered thousands of dollars in microbets, as several bettors exploded in anger at the awkward swing. One bettor, a Dominican Republic native living in New York, lost $4,000 on the strike, his second major loss on Clase over a two-year period. The losing bets captured the attention of jurors over the final three days of testimony at the Clase trial in Brooklyn.

Clase, a two-time American League reliever of the year, is facing charges that he provided advanced information on the speed and results of certain pitches to a group of bettors in furtherance of a criminal conspiracy. Enthony Enthony Diaz, a star witness for the government, completed two days of dramatic testimony on Friday afternoon.

The former MLB All-Star is on trial with Luis Ortiz, another Guardians pitcher accused of deliberately rigging pitches for betting purposes. Diaz testified that he received advanced information from a Clase associate who claimed that the bets were a “sure thing.” While Diaz lost on the Pages’ wagers, along with a series of 2023 microbets involving Manny Machado, he proved to be far more successful when betting on Ortiz.

In total, Diaz won more than $30,000 on bets related to Ortiz, including several made with inside information provided by Enoc Pena, prosecutors allege. Despite the allegations, defense attorneys attempted to discredit Diaz by informing the jury of his lengthy criminal record, including his admissions of bank and check fraud. The intense cross-examination, followed by an impassioned re-direct from prosecutors provided fireworks before jurors were excused for the weekend.

Swinging at a pitch in the dirt

Prior to the testimony from Diaz on Thursday, jurors heard from FBI Special Agent Noah Bilger. In responding to direct examination from Assistant US Attorney Sean Sherman, Bilger referenced betting records from the May 2025 pitch to Pages. A spreadsheet on display in the courtroom contained more than a dozen bets from co-conspirators of the defendants. Every bet, according to the spreadsheet, resulted in a loss. Overall, the bettors lost $11,028 in aggregate.

SS: Was it a ball?

NB: No

SS: Why not?

NB: The batter swung

SS: Did any of the bettors win?

NB: No

SS: Why not?

NB: The batter swung

Bilger’s testimony predated an appearance by Richard Busick, another agent with the FBI. Busick, a special agent with the FBI’s Cellular Analysis Survey Team (CAST), previously testified at the wire fraud trial of FTX CEO Sam Bankman-Fried in 2023. There, he gave testimony on the location of the location of crypto executive’s mobile phones based on cell phone tower records. Busick’s expertise covered comparable subjects at the Clase trial as he testified on Pena’s whereabouts based on geolocation data reviewed by the FBI. The records tied Pena to Clase’s residence at the same time he recorded numerous pings from his DraftKings’ app.

Falsified loan applications

Pena, a cooperating witness for the government, has emerged as a controversial figure in the case. While the bettor signed a cooperation agreement with the government ahead of the trial, prosecutors indicated that it is unlikely he will be called as a witness. Attorneys for the defense have labelled him as “uncredible,” based on his history in providing factual inaccuracies on loan and immigration applications, as well as tax forms.

The credibility of Diaz has also been scrutinised by the defense based on his prior transgressions. On cross-examination from Elizabeth Geddes, an attorney for Ortiz, Diaz admitted to falsifying loan applications on at least five occasions while defrauding banks of at least $85,000.

Diaz also admitted to providing Pena with his password to an account at an unnamed bank to keep the loan “current” while he visited the Dominican Republic. Diaz admitted to giving Pena his account information at Key Bank, but did not recall providing him with access to a separate account at MCU Bank. When asked if a fictitious check of $4,221 bearing his name was deposited into an account, Diaz responded that he had not seen it before. Pressed further by Geddes, Diaz only replied that the bank “blocked” his account.

Large wins on Ortiz

On redirect from Assistant US Attorney Eric Silverberg, Diaz admitted to committing bank fraud, but appeared circumspect on the nature of the fraudulent checks. Silverberg also informed Diaz that he ranked as the most profitable bettor on Ortiz pitches, netting at least $31,418 alone in 2025. The wagers were tracked at four regulated sportsbooks: DraftKings, FanDuel, ESPN BET and Caesars Sportsbook.

Through dealings with Pena, Ortiz told the jury that the bettor gave him inside info on four pitches he believed were rigged: two from Clase and two from Ortiz. The Clase pitches against Machado and Pages resulted in losing bets, while the Ortiz pitches against Randy Arozarena of the Seattle Mariners and Pedro Pages of the St. Louis Cardinals resulted in wins. The defense denies that the pitches were rigged, while maintaining that the pitchers had no knowledge of the scheme. Pena, they claim, sold false information to bettors on pitches that were not manipulated.

The trial will resume on Monday with several government witnesses yet to testify. It is unclear how long it will take for the defense to present its case. The prosecution intends to rest before Thanksgiving.

Subscribe to the iGaming newsletter