Pokémon cards should face greater gambling scrutiny, says Lord Foster
Lord Foster has challenged the Gambling Commission’s view that buying Pokémon cards falls outside gambling legislation.
First reported by Kobe Post, Foster argued that the established resale market of Pokémon cards raised questions about whether they can count as “money’s worth” under the Gambling Act 2005.
In a letter dated 21 July 2026, Foster, chair of Peers for Gambling Reform (PGR), said it was “not immediately apparent” why the cards should not meet that definition when some have a clear financial value and can be sold through card shops and online marketplaces.
Foster said cards that “clearly possess an objectively ascertainable financial value and can readily be exchanged for cash” warranted further explanation of the legal basis for excluding them from the definition.
He contrasted Pokémon cards with digital items acquired through video-game loot boxes, saying the cards are traded through “mainstream, legitimate and entirely lawful commercial channels”.
While acknowledging that many people collect cards for enjoyment, he said the Commission should also consider how they are “bought, sold and valued”, as well as their appeal to younger audiences.
What are their cards?
Pokémon cards are often played as part of Pokémon Trading Card Game (PTCG). Players will ‘play’ cards to their opponent based on characters and abilities in Pokémon with an aim to win the other players cards.
Pokemon cards have experienced a huge wave of popularity in the last few years. The rise of content creators and games such as Pokemon GO can be attributed to this popularity.
Demand and price has also followed suit. Last month, a man in Woking sold his Pokémon collection for £1.56 million at auction, per the BBC.
Pokémon cards were “a particularly good case to pursue because there is clear evidence that cash trading does take place”, Foster added in his letter.
The Commission disagrees
The Commission’s acting chief executive, Sarah Gardner, replied on 11 August that the possibility of later resale did not, by itself, mean the sale of Pokémon cards constituted gambling.
“In our view, the fact that Pokémon cards may subsequently be traded or sold on a secondary market does not, of itself, mean that their sale constitutes gambling,” she wrote.
Gardner said Parliament had not intended the Act to cover trading cards or football stickers merely because their purchase involved an element of chance.
She added that the Commission could examine products that might meet the legal definition of gambling, including services in which gambling-like features are built into what would otherwise be a shopping platform or experience.
However, the regulator was “not currently undertaking activity in relation to the purchase or trading of collectable cards or stickers”, Gardner said.
The Commission must protect children and other vulnerable people from gambling-related harm, she added, but it has to operate within the definitions set by Parliament. Any changes to those definitions, or to the regulator’s powers, were for the government and Parliament to decide.
Gambling in video gaming
Foster has previously called for greater scrutiny of gambling-like mechanics in video games. In a follow-up email, he described Pokémon cards as part of a broader group of “gambling-like” products that “can lead to real gambling”.
Gambling-like mechanics have been under fire across Europe this month. The newly drafted EU Digital Fairness Act would regulate paid “variable reward systems”, defined in the draft as virtual items offering random rewards or variable odds that are acquired through payment or paid-for virtual currency.
“Variable reward systems that offer random rewards or variable odds, such as loot boxes, wheels of fortune, or collectible card packs, are prone not only to cause unwanted spending by consumers but can also be harmful due to the fact that they share the speculative features of gambling”, explained the Recital.
A review of the Gambling Act
Ford also said a 2020 House of Lords report on gambling, in whose work he was involved, had specifically recommended changing the definition of gambling.
Fresh scrutiny on the details of the Gambling Act 2005 was launched in recent weeks by the Gambling Policy Commission (GPC). The GPC, established at the start of November, has launched a review of the gambling laws and legislations in the UK.
Particular emphasis was placed on a review of the Gambling Act itself and whether a new Act would be the next step.
iGB reached out to Lord Foster for comment but had not received a response by time of publication.
