ECJ sidesteps ruling on compatibility of Malta’s Bill 55 with EU law
The European Court of Justice (ECJ) has declined to rule on whether Malta’s controversial Bill 55 is compatible with EU law, declaring a request from an Austrian court for a preliminary ruling inadmissible.
The case centred on Malta’s Bill 55, introduced in 2023, which prohibits legal actions against Maltese-licensed gambling operators and prevents the recognition and enforcement in Malta of foreign judgments resulting from such actions, including activities in foreign grey markets.
The bill has come under fire from those who feel it’s contrary to EU law, and in April this year, the ECJ ruled European member states were able to initiate legal proceedings against operators for not adhering to their gambling laws.
Spielerschutz Sigma, an Austrian litigation funder, had secured several rulings in cases from players seeking refunds of gambling losses from MGA-licensed operators active in Austria without the required local licence.
Inadmissible referral adds uncertainty
Spielerschutz Sigma sought the views of a legal adviser on the compatibility of Bill 55 with EU law, with the adviser sharing his view that it was incompatible and would therefore not be applicable to enforcement proceedings in Malta.
However, a Maltese court rejected Spielerschutz Sigma’s request for the judgement in Austria to be applied in Malta, leading to the litigation funder suing the adviser, seeking compensation for fees and losses incurred after relying on his opinion.
The Austrian court then referred questions over the case to the ECJ, seeking a preliminary ruling.
But on Thursday, the ECJ ruled the referral was inadmissible, adding to the uncertainty over whether Bill 55 is indeed compatible with EU law.
Why was the request deemed inadmissible?
The ECJ ruled the Austrian court’s request was inadmissible because an interpretation of EU law was not necessary to resolve the dispute between Spielerschutz Sigma and its legal adviser.
The dispute concerned whether the adviser had acted negligently when providing an opinion on the compatibility of Bill 55 with EU law.
Under Austrian law, the key question was whether that opinion was reasonably defensible based on the legal framework and information available at the time it was issued.
The ECJ said the Austrian court could assess whether the legal adviser had fulfilled their obligations without first determining whether Malta’s legislation was compatible with EU law.
“In those circumstances, the Court notes that the lawfulness and proper performance of the reciprocal obligations of the parties to the legal consultation at issue are independent of the question of the compatibility of the relevant Maltese legislation with EU law,” the ECJ said.
“Consequently, the Court finds that the interpretation of EU law which it would need to adopt in answer to the questions referred for a preliminary ruling would not meet an objective need for the resolution of the dispute in question and would not, therefore, be necessary for that resolution.”
Bill 55 compatibility remains unresolved
Speaking after the court’s decision, ECJ Press Officer Jacques René Zammit confirmed to iGB that the judgment did not address the compatibility of Bill 55 with EU law.
“In this case, it did not go into that, no,” Zammit said.
He added that other cases currently before the ECJ could eventually result in a ruling on the issue.