Home > Uncategorized > Ban this sort of thing!

Ban this sort of thing!

| By Jon Bruford | Reading Time: 6 minutes
Jon Bruford takes a look at the recent C4 fake game show 'Bradley Walsh's Million Pound Shot ' and likes what he sees…kind of.

I must admit, the TV show in question caught me by surprise. I wasn’t watching it, it wasn’t that the ‘twist’ threw me. It’s more that its existence was completely unexpected, and its facile nature a genuine surprise. But it’s not all bad, honestly. There were things to love about the show, just not what the producers probably intended.

For those that missed the industry uproar, UK broadcaster Channel 4 recently showed the opening episode of a new game show series, Bradley Walsh’s Million Pound Shot – except it wasn’t a game show. The format was new, and had a huge twist in the tale: players bet their own money in order to have a chance to win a fortune. I mean, on the face of it that’s pretty compelling telly, am I right?

The Apprentice was a game show too!

I’m not snobby about game shows, and I know many people are. I had a girlfriend once who said game shows were designed for the lowest common denominator in society, and she dismissed them as being for ‘idiots’. The very same girlfriend’s favourite TV show was The Apprentice, and she actually threw a tantrum when I explained it was a game show; she wasn’t having it at all. She said no, it’s a job interview. No, it’s a game show and the prize is a one-year contract… We weren’t going out for long, let’s put it that way.

I digress.

If you have a message to convey, game shows are a great way to open the door because they are designed to appeal and communicate to a huge cross-section of society, and they do it behind the façade of light entertainment. I bring this up because it’s important to note that an awful lot of people in the world simply believe what is put in front of them, and the studio audience in Bradley Walsh’s Million Pound Shot definitely, 100% bought what they were being sold – both before and after the true nature of the programme was revealed.

No gold stars

If the platform used to communicate is the right one, people – all of us, pretty much – will believe what we hear. When I was in sixth form, we had a guest lecturer come in one day. She said something to my media studies group that was not only wrong, it was easily provable as incorrect. Now, I didn’t get a gold star for pointing anything out that day but it did help me realise that experts are not, in fact, always experts. Bradley Walsh’s Million Pound Shot was a wonderful case of experts held up as experts, to tell us of our wicked ways, when a serious chunk of what we saw was wildly incorrect.

So the show starts with three players in the classic game show format, they introduce themselves, and in this particular show they tell the host how broke they are. Yes, really. They answer a question for the chance to go through and gamble for bigger prizes. So first up, they’re playing each other initially, then once they get through to the next round, it’s them against the machine, kind of.

Revealed to be fake

The host emphasises frequently how the player is using his own money to gamble here, and it’s a big risk. Each time he has to fund his betting account on the show, he has to put his bank card in a reader, and enter his PIN (note to the producers – the card is too shiny and new, and he hasn’t signed the back. Even if I had been watching live this would have left me suspicious).

In a series of disastrous game show shenanigans, our hero loses all his money and is left in a pit of despai – except this is a game show in the style of M. Night Shyamalan, and it’s then revealed that the player is an actor, and the whole thing has been put together to illustrate how the gambling industry preys on players.

Pretty clever

I genuinely think this is pretty clever – it has huge impact and the studio audience is aghast, horrified. And they’ve bought every single word of it, even more so as it’s illustrated boldly afterwards (oh, those wonderful experts) how the casino industry is so utterly predatory.

Except, there is so much that’s not true. One expert says “look, they’ve removed the concept of money from the equation, using tokens is a way they get players to gamble more“. On face value, you’d say “yeah, the bastards! I can see how that works!” But it doesn’t make sense since the player has had to use his card, a reader, and input his PIN each time he wants to boost his balance. This is a period of cognitive dissonance for the player, a chance for them to step out of the actual play and take a second to think. It’s how time out interventions work in online gambling, for example.

Raises fair points

You can’t fund a slot machine (or, I think, gamble in any way) direct from a bank account anywhere in the world – this means there is always a buffer between the player and the gamble, where money has to be moved. It’s an element of pre-commitment, and it’s really important – a stage where the player can change their mind and not drain their bank account without realising it.

We also get in to losses disguised as wins. Now, if you’ve ever played a traditional slot machine you’ll know this is a very difficult thing to argue against. The sounds for a win or a loss can be very similar, and it’s not too much to ask any regulator to specify how the sounds should differ in their regulations.

Dopamine trigger and free bet territory

Disguised losses are a dopamine trigger and then some. But – take it up with the regulator. Also, within the context of the show again this doesn’t make sense, because they show his overall win/loss on a huge screen and it’s very openly illustrated.

We also come into free bet territory. Again, if this is your issue – this is a regulatory issue. The industry has whole teams of people working solely on licensing compliance. Change the rules and the way this works will change, it’s that simple. So often the industry is criticised for what are ultimately regulatory concerns. Hey, if the rules are set, any industry will play to those rules. That’s why they’re there – but a TV show complaining of the industry working to those rules seems a bit wide of the mark to say the least.

Industry response

The gambling industry was given a few captions at the end of the show to respond to what was shown. According to a post-show release, the Betting and Gaming Council submitted a “detailed response” to the programme makers, “providing evidence to rebut a number of claims”. Sadly, it seems that as the show aired without taking any of what the BGC said in, and this is so often the way – if your voice is affiliated to the gambling industry in any way, whatever you say, no matter what you use to illustrate or support it, is ignored. The show talked about gambling with credit cards: you haven’t been able to do that in the UK for years! As for the section where the contestants introduce themselves, even the lightest KYC check would have high-lit them as players without a significant disposable income.

No one there to dispute the premise

OK, so the producers would not have had an industry representative there to dispute what was being said. Why would they? It’s not sensationalist enough, and it doesn’t have the emotional impact they’re after if the claims of a fictional game show are disputed, however factually. But I wonder if they ran the show past the gambling regulator? Or even considered having someone there from the Gambling Commission while it was being filmed? I’m thinking they probably didn’t, because facts and good, emotional shock TV don’t often mix.

It’s worth pointing out as well that almost all game shows rely on a strong element of gambling for their finale. The contestants have won X amount of prizes or cash, do they want to gamble it to win a bigger prize? This is a staple of prime-time and has been for as long as television game shows have been around.

The bright side

The industry response could have been different though. What the producers have essentially done for us, and why this is a slightly missed opportunity, is they’ve shown the world what an unregulated industry looks like. What an offshore operator can and will do, and what happens when players move to unregulated operators. That’s what we should have done – say “THANK YOU!” to the producers and send them flowers, because there were a ton of things on show (gleefully digested by a shocked and disgusted audience) that were simply either not true, or were issues to take to the regulator.

The audience at home and in the studio were misled, hugely, by what they saw. While I am not belittling the harm that gambling can do, I have come to the only reasonable conclusion I can on reviewing this show and its inaccuracies and falsehoods: ban game shows. It’s the only way.

Subscribe to the iGaming newsletter