Home > Legal & compliance > Legal > Bill 55 debate continues after ECJ sidesteps EU law question

Bill 55 debate continues after ECJ sidesteps EU law question

| By Kyle Goldsmith
Malta’s controversial Bill 55 remains under scrutiny after the ECJ declined to rule on its compatibility with EU law.
Bill 55 ECJ

The European Court of Justice (ECJ) sidestepped a ruling on the compatibility of Malta’s Bill 55 on Thursday, though legal experts tell iGB it wasn’t a surprising move.

Felix Hohenthanner, a lawyer for the Austrian law firm Rapani Rechtsanwälte, said the ECJ’s decision was expected.

“There were rumours that it was a made-up case, only for the reference to the ECJ,” he told iGB. “There are procedural requisites to go to the ECJ, and it wasn’t enough for it, so it was just a procedural decision.”

Spielerschutz Sigma, an Austrian litigation funder, had secured judgements from Austrian courts for players seeking gambling-loss refunds from Maltese-licensed operators offering services without local licences.

After Malta refused recognition of an Austrian judgment, the Austrian court referred questions to the ECJ over Bill 55, which was introduced in 2023 and bars the recognition and enforcement in Malta of foreign judgments arising from claims on foreign soil, including those involving operators active in unlicensed foreign markets.

However, the ECJ ruled on Thursday that the referral was inadmissible. Spielerschutz Sigma had sued a legal adviser who shared his opinion that Bill 55 was incompatible with EU law and wouldn’t be applicable to Maltese enforcement proceedings.

The ECJ stated that the dispute between Spielerschutz Sigma and its adviser did not require an interpretation of EU law and was therefore inadmissible.

Terence Cassar, partner at the Maltese law firm GTG, concurred with Hohenthanner, saying: “It was very clear that the underlying case from which the referral was presented. This was essentially a legal malpractice lawsuit. That’s what it was, and it has almost nothing to do with what the case was.

“A court always needs to decide based on what is presented to it.”

Players face continued hurdles to recover losses

The ECJ’s decision on Thursday essentially means very little for Bill 55, with the key question of its compatibility with EU law unresolved.

As Hohenthanner explained, it continues to prove difficult for Austrian players to achieve refunds on losses incurred with Maltese-licensed operators in Malta.

“Unless there are any other assets in other European countries, it’s getting harder and harder for players to get their funds,” he stated.

The compatibility of Bill 55

Bill 55 has come under scrutiny from those who feel it’s contrary to EU law, with the ECJ ruling in April that member states were able to initiate legal proceedings against operators that failed to adhere to their gambling laws.

When asked if Malta’s Bill 55 undermines the EU’s rules on recognising court judgements between member states, Cassar responds: “In my view, that’s an absolute no.

“Malta’s position on this point has been the same for more than 20 years at this stage. It’s a public policy position that we took. It was even there when we were back in the part of joining the EU.

“So to me, it’s a definite no. And the rules themselves recognise that local states, as member states, can make exceptions based on their public policy.”

New ECJ referral could bring definitive ruling

Simon Priglinger-Simader, president of the Austrian Association for Betting and Gaming (OVWG), said the ECJ’s decision on Thursday was “understandable from an EU law perspective”.

The OVWG is keeping a close eye on the developments, with Priglinger-Simader adding: “As the OVWG, we will continue monitoring the further proceedings related to Malta’s Bill 55 closely and will carefully assess their potential implications for our members and player claims cases in Austria.”

In October, Malta’s Court of Appeal referred questions to the ECJ over Bill 55’s compatibility with EU law.

Hohenthanner suggested this could be the referral needed to achieve a definitive ruling from the ECJ on Bill 55.

“This will be the case where the CGU will decide on the merits on Bill 55, in my opinion,” he declared. “Maybe in 2027, maybe a little bit more.”

Subscribe to the iGaming newsletter